Actions Speak as Loud as Words
Author: Staff Editor Sarah Huppert
State v. King, No. 129,201 (Kan. Ct. App., Oct. 30, 2026).
Issue: Can a defendant’s actual or attempted violence provide a factual basis for a criminal threat plea, even when the same conduct could be charged as assault?
Answer: Yes. Criminal threats can be communicated nonverbally, and conduct may constitute a threat even if it could also support a different charge.
Facts: King ran toward a parked car with a machete and attempted to hit the driver through an open window. As the car drove off, King’s machete struck a rear window. Car occupants testified they feared being struck. Originally charged with aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and criminal damage to property, King accepted a plea agreement to amended charges of felony criminal threat and aggravated assault with intent to commit a felony. The parties agreed to use preliminary-hearing testimony as the factual basis for the plea. Before sentencing, King moved to withdraw his plea, arguing that no factual basis supported the criminal threat conviction, upon which the aggravated assault conviction was predicated. The district court denied his motion.
Discussion: Although a lack of factual basis may establish good cause for plea withdrawal, the appellate court found sufficient factual basis for King’s criminal threat plea.
Criminal threat includes a threat to commit violence communicated with intent to place another in fear. The court rejected King’s argument that actual or attempted violence cannot constitute a criminal threat. Criminal threats may be communicated through nonverbal actions, and intent may be inferred from physical conduct. Actual violence may constitute a threat of violence as well, even when the same conduct might otherwise be charged as a different crime.
The court noted that charging multiple offenses arising from the same conduct could raise multiplicity concerns, but that issue was not before the court.
Key Authorities:
Kan. Stat. Ann. § 21-5415(a)(1) (defining criminal threat, including threat to commit violence communicated with intent to place another in fear).
State v. Ebaben, 281 P.3d 129 (2012) (distinguished; insufficient factual basis for plea may establish good cause for withdrawal).
State v. Howell & Taylor, 601 P.2d 1141 (1979) (physical conduct can communicate a threat of bodily harm even when the same conduct could constitute another offense).